A stepper motor is a type of motor that moves in small, precise steps, making it ideal for CNC machines , 3D printers and other applications. However, not all stepper motors are created equal. Traditional stepper motors are open-loop systems, meaning they do not have feedback mechanisms to ensure accuracy.
What does this really mean?
Your CNC machine or 3D printer does not have a way of knowing if its toolhead is positioned relative to the programmed coordinates and movement of the motor.
A closed-loop stepper motor, however, is a stepper motor that has a feedback mechanism to ensure its position accuracy. The feedback mechanism typically consists of an encoder that provides real-time position information to the motor controller. The motor controller compares the actual position of the motor to the desired position and adjusts the motor's movement accordingly.
Are there options?
There are three types of closed-loop control for stepper motors:
- Step-loss compensation: This type of closed-loop control involves reactive position correction at the end of the move. It detects any step losses that may have occurred during the motion and compensates for them by adjusting the position. While this method provides basic control and can help improve positioning accuracy, it relies on detecting errors after they have occurred.
- Load position control: With load position control, the closed-loop system continuously and in real-time corrects the position of the motor. It monitors the actual position of the motor shaft and adjusts it to match the desired position. This type of control offers more precise and accurate positioning, ensuring that the motor stays on track during the entire motion. It provides a higher level of control without requiring complex control algorithms.
- Servo control: Servo control offers the most comprehensive level of control over stepper motors. It enables complete control of torque and position, allowing for precise and dynamic motion control. Servo control systems employ feedback mechanisms to constantly monitor and adjust the motor's position, speed, and torque, ensuring high accuracy and responsiveness. This level of control is typically used in applications where the highest level of precision and performance is required.
Closed-loop stepper motors offer several advantages over traditional open-loop stepper motors, effectively eliminating the limitations and drawbacks of their predecessors:
- Longer bearing service life due to less heat and vibration
- Achieve high torque even at high rotational speeds for reduced acceleration times
- Precise positioning through monitoring and correction
PROVerXL 4030 V2 is available now! Genmitsu is thrilled to introduce our latest CNC router featuring the state-of-the-art step-loss compensation closed-loop motor. Experience enhanced precision and faster speed like never before. Stay tuned for the official launch where we'll unveil the remarkable capabilities of this machine.
6 comments
Hi, are you planning to use closed loop motors on other models like CNC 4040 ?
Thx
i was very excited to get my CNC until I started having problems
For this to be really useful it should know to “back up” to the original position not complete another revolution. I can think of all kinds of issues this would cause, thus it is not so much a cure but a detriment. Once steps are lost, in most cases your job is ruined, see examples below.
If my router carriage with a stepper on each side gets out of alignment due to lost steps and the stepper “advances” to the next shaft alignment then the carriage is a full rotation out on one side.
If this stepper is used to drive a carriage on a lathe and you are threading and the stepper loses steps and the stepper then goes one full rotation then the threading is ruined. Same if the stepper is driving the cross slide on a lathe. These are simple examples.
Maybe I am missing a step? and not understanding how this cures anything to have the stepper advance a full rotation on it’s own?
Idea ! . Perche non dotare il CNC 6050 di motori passo-passo con circuito ad anello chiuso ?
Will the closed loop and controller be offered as upgrades to the ProVerXL V1? I would love to fit this to mine as I already have that machine